About Penny's Five Star Pizza

At Penny's Five Star Pizza, we bring real New York style pizza to every order that leaves our kitchen. Our pizza comes from real technique and real care, not shortcuts. We've spent years perfecting our recipes and our process. As Benett T. shared, "Ive lived all over mid west, traveled the US for work, and have not ever found better cheese sticks than penny’s." Our customers trust us because they can taste the authenticity in every slice. We're proud to serve the Lake Odessa community with pizza done the right way.